Peanut Butter Creme Sandwich – Maxine's Heavenly
Peanut Butter Creme Sandwich
4.83 / 5.0
24 reviews
Sold Out
Our Peanut Butter Creme Sandwiches come with an unbelievably smooth peanut butter cream filling sandwiched between two chewy peanut butter cookies. There is no way we could've packed any more peanut flavor into these insanely delicious treats.
This box holds 3 individually wrapped oatmeal creme sandwiches.
PLEASE CHOOSE QUANTITY: Buy a case and save!
1 Box - $5.498 Boxes - $37.99Pack Size:1 Box - $5.49
1 Box - $5.498 Boxes - $37.99
This product is unavailable
See our shipping and returns policy
Details
This 4.6oz box holds 3 individually wrapped oatmeal creme sandwiches.
Ingredients
INGREDIENTS: Cookies (Gluten Free Oats*, Coconut Oil and/or Sustainable Palm Fruit Oil, Dates, Organic Coconut Sugar, Peanut Butter, Water, Peanut Flour, Prebiotic Acacia Fiber, Flaxseed, Sunflower Lecithin, Baking Powder, Sea Salt,
Baking Soda), Creme Filling (Coconut Oil and/or Sustainable Palm Fruit Oil, Powdered Sugar, Organic Coconut Nectar, Peanut Butter, Peanut Flour, Tapioca Starch, Prebiotic Acacia Fiber, Sea Salt).
*Glyphosate Free Oats
CONTAINS: Peanuts.
Manufactured on shared equipment with products containing peanuts and tree nuts.
Nutrition
[More details](/content/products/peanut-butter-cream-pie "Peanut Butter Creme Sandwich"/index.html)
Customer Reviews
4.83 based on 24 reviews
21
2
1
0
0
See all reviews
\ \ 100.0](https://app.judge.me/reviews/stores/maxinesheavenly)
\ \ 91.7](https://app.judge.me/reviews/stores/maxinesheavenly)
Sort by Most RecentHighest RatingLowest RatingOnly PicturesPictures FirstVideos FirstMost HelpfulMost Recent
04/13/2026
Lillian B.
Amazing GF treat!
These tase incredible and are the best GF cookies!! Addictive!
Review collected via store invitation
03/15/2026
Janice M.
Peanut Butter Creme Sandwiches are Additive
Tthe Oatmeal Creme Sandwiches are delicious. The Peanut Butter Creme are moist, not too sweet and and hit my crave button. I highly recommend them if peanut butter is one of your favorite flavors.
Review collected via store invitation
01/10/2026
Jennifer
So delicious - so do not hessitate. Buy them!
Review written in Shop App
11/13/2025
Etherius
PEANUT BUTTER HEAVEN
Oh, please make these available in whole foods or availed for shipping year-round.
The gingerbread and peanut butter cream sandwiches are my absolute favorite!
These are perfect for a sweet tooth craving that does more than just knock that sweet tooth down. Healthy fiber content and dates make them functional too!
The peanut butter cream filling reminds me of a specific birthday cake frosting my mother used to make when i was a wee lass. Almost like a peanut butter candy filling (think, buckeyes!) but with just the right amount of sweetness. The cookie is slightly firmer than the oatmeal cookie, but not quite chewy. Perfect for a cream sandwich.
I'll be stocking up on these!
Review collected from a store visitor
11/05/2025
Lydia S.
I'm not sure
I've sent you email about my experience with your cookies. I'm probably sending the notes wrong and Im not sure what I'm doing wrong. But you got the one from me and I sent another.
Review collected via store invitation
123
Sweetened by Nature™
Our decadent, naturally sweetened cookies make it easy to turn your love/hate relationship with sugar into one that’s ALL LOVE. Having a sweet tooth is natural—the sugar you eat should be natural too!
In an effort to be “healthy”, many have veered towards manufactured zero calorie sugar alcohols and refined sweeteners like stevia and monk fruit to satisfy their cravings. But Mother Nature tastes pretty good all on her own, and our bodies prefer it!
So we started with Maxine’s original recipe and swapped out the unhealthy ingredients for better ones, including substituting refined, bleached white sugar with coconut sugar and dates.
You may also like
\ \ Sold out](/content/products/oatmeal-creme-sandwich/index.html)
4.53 / 5.0\ \ 75 reviews Oatmeal Creme Sandwich\ \ \ From $5.49 to $37.99 Out of Stock
\ \ Sold out](/content/products/chocolate-creme-sandwich/index.html)
4.43 / 5.0\ \ 30 reviews Chocolate Creme Sandwich\ \ \ From $5.49 to $37.99 Out of Stock
\ \ Sold out](/content/products/birthday-cake-creme-sandwich/index.html)
4.68 / 5.0\ \ 25 reviews Birthday Cake Creme Sandwich\ \ \ From $5.49 to $37.99 Out of Stock
\ \ Sold out](/content/products/best-sellers-bundle/index.html)
4.67 / 5.0\ \ 516 reviews Best Seller's Bundle\ \ \ $29.99 $35.95
One-time purchase$29.99
Subscribe & save5%$28.49
Delivery every 30 daysDelivery every 30 days:Delivery every 30 days
Subscription details
How subscriptions work
Products are automatically delivered on your schedule. No obligation, modify or cancel your subscription anytime.
Out of Stock
\ \ Sold out](/content/products/crispy-cookies-bundle/index.html)
5.0 / 5.0\ \ 66 reviews Crispy Cookies Bundle\ \ \ $29.99 $35.95 Out of Stock
\ \ Sold out](/content/products/cinnamon-speculoos-crunch/index.html)
4.74 / 5.0\ \ 68 reviews Cinnamon Crunch\ \ \ $6.99
One-time purchase$6.99
Subscribe & save5%$6.64
Delivery every 1 monthDelivery every 2 monthsDelivery every 3 monthsDelivery every 6 monthsDelivery:Delivery every 1 month
Subscription details
How subscriptions work
Products are automatically delivered on your schedule. No obligation, modify or cancel your subscription anytime.
Out of Stock
\ \ Sold out](/content/products/chocolate-chip/index.html)
4.81 / 5.0\ \ 75 reviews Chocolate Chip\ \ \ $6.99
One-time purchase$6.99
Subscribe & save5%$6.64
Delivery every 1 monthDelivery every 2 monthsDelivery every 3 monthsDelivery every 6 monthsDelivery:Delivery every 1 month
Subscription details
How subscriptions work
Products are automatically delivered on your schedule. No obligation, modify or cancel your subscription anytime.
Out of Stock
\ \ Sold out](/content/products/peanut-butter-chocolate-chunk/index.html)
4.7 / 5.0\ \ 393 reviews Peanut Butter Chocolate Chunk\ \ \ $6.99
One-time purchase$6.99
Subscribe & save5%$6.64
Delivery every 1 monthDelivery every 2 monthsDelivery every 3 monthsDelivery every 6 monthsDelivery:Delivery every 1 month
Subscription details
How subscriptions work
Products are automatically delivered on your schedule. No obligation, modify or cancel your subscription anytime.
Out of Stock
\ \ Sold out](/content/products/cinnamon-oatmeal-raisin/index.html)
4.65 / 5.0\ \ 245 reviews Cinnamon Oatmeal Raisin\ \ \ $6.99
One-time purchase$6.99
Subscribe & save5%$6.64
Delivery every 1 monthDelivery every 2 monthsDelivery every 3 monthsDelivery every 6 monthsDelivery:Delivery every 1 month
Subscription details
How subscriptions work
Products are automatically delivered on your schedule. No obligation, modify or cancel your subscription anytime.
Out of Stock
\ \ Sold out](/content/products/chocolate-chocolate-chunk/index.html)
4.65 / 5.0\ \ 590 reviews Double Chocolate Chunk\ \ \ $6.99
One-time purchase$6.99
Subscribe & save5%$6.64
Delivery every 1 monthDelivery every 2 monthsDelivery every 3 monthsDelivery every 6 monthsDelivery:Delivery every 1 month
Subscription details
How subscriptions work
Products are automatically delivered on your schedule. No obligation, modify or cancel your subscription anytime.
Out of Stock
\ \ Sold out](/content/products/ultimate-variety-bundle/index.html)
4.0 / 5.0\ \ 13 reviews Ultimate Variety Bundle\ \ \ $59.99 $64.90 Out of Stock
\ \ Sold out](/content/products/cookies-creme-sandwich/index.html)
3.79 / 5.0\ \ 28 reviews Cookies & Creme Sandwich\ \ \ From $5.49 to $37.99 Out of Stock
maxinesheavenly.com
maxinesheavenly.com is blocked
This page has been blocked by an extension
- Try disabling your extensions.
ERR_BLOCKED_BY_CLIENT
Reload
This page has been blocked by an extension
maxinesheavenly.com
maxinesheavenly.com is blocked
This page has been blocked by an extension
- Try disabling your extensions.
ERR_BLOCKED_BY_CLIENT
Reload
This page has been blocked by an extension
SHOP
INFO
HELP/POLICIES
Newsletter
Join our newsletter for sweet deals and news.
Right arrow long
© 2026 Maxine's Heavenly.
Right arrow long
Order Online
★ Reviews
Let customers speak for us
4.67 based on 2897 reviews
2262
433
130
38
34
See all reviews
\ \ 1878](https://app.judge.me/reviews/stores/maxinesheavenly)
\ \ 166](https://app.judge.me/reviews/stores/maxinesheavenly)
Product Reviews (2886)Shop Reviews (11)
Sort by Most RecentHighest RatingLowest RatingOnly PicturesPictures FirstVideos FirstMost HelpfulMost Recent
07/30/2026
Sheila N.
Delicious but often not available
I love these. But hard to find now and long delivery time
07/01/2026
Barbara W.
Loved treats for my grand who can’t have gluten and eggs.
Great variety of cookies for this that have gluten intolerance .
06/24/2026
Dee
Chocolate crème sandwich
I bought these at sprouts in Tennessee. They are very good. Just keep selling out!
06/19/2026
Caryn B.
Delicious
The cookies were definitely one of the best cookies I’ve ever had. Unfortunately, due to the extremely high cost of shipping I don’t know if I’ll be able to order them again.
06/16/2026
Chelsea
Amazing
Just found these for the first time in my local small health food store and OMG they are DIVINE. I’m ready to go buy them out tomorrow because I haven’t tasted anything this good that’s plant based in decades of being vegan.
123
Chat
Your cart is empty.